Evaluation Criteria
There are two main categories of evaluation:
UNDERSTANDING
• A thorough understanding of the text, including language, character/plot (monologue) and literary/poetic elements(sonnet).
Within this category, there are three subcategories: Meaning, Language and Character (monologue only).
COMMUNICATION & EXPRESSION
• An effective delivery of the interpretation.
• An unaffected, artistic range that includes the effective use of body and voice and demonstrates an individual point-of-view.
Within this category, there are three subcategories: Vocal, Physical and Ownership.
A high scoring presentation demonstrates the following:
Monologue
- Meaning: A sophisticated understanding of the meaning of the speech and its context within the play.
- Language: An excellent, nuanced understanding of all words, metaphor or imagery in speech and any poetic elements (rhythm, rhyme, etc.).
- Character: An accurate portrayal of the character with a detailed understanding their point of view, status and emotional state.
- Vocal: A clear, effective vocal expression filled with choices that fully reflect the character.
- Physical: A clear, appropriate physical expression filled with choices that fully reflect the character and his/her intentions.
- Ownership: A demonstration of impressive confidence/poise with a skillful use of performance energy that both constantly maintains a connection to their character and captivates the audience.
Sonnet
- Meaning: A sophisticated understanding of the meaning of the poem and its context (messages, allusions, ironies, tonal shifts, etc.)
- Language: An excellent, nuanced understanding of all words, metaphor or imagery in the poem and any poetic elements (rhythm, rhyme scheme, etc.).
- Vocal: A clear, effective vocal expression filled with choices that fully reflect the poem and its structure.
- Physical: A clear, appropriate physical expression filled with choices that expertly enhance and illuminate the poem and its language.
- Ownership: A demonstration of impressive confidence/poise with a skillful use of performance energy that both constantly maintains a connection to the poem and captivates the audience.
For more information, see the Monologue Scoring Rubric and Sonnet Scoring Rubric on the Judge Resources Page.
Return to Judge Resources